It's like night and day 'De-Lovely' bills itself as the antithesis of the
Hollywood version of Cole Porter's complicated married life.
Party's on.
The scene is a masked ball in 1920s Venice and on
stage, under a drizzle of streamers, Elvis Costello is
leading a five-piece band through a boisterous version
of Cole Porter's "Let's Misbehave." The music's
swinging, everyone's dancing, and the bosoms — both
men's and women's — are pleasurably heaving.
Costello's voice slides through the lyrics like a
trombone. He bends his body backward — fingers
snapping, shiny shoes tapping — and the band kicks the
dancers into an orgy of exuberance, like King Louie
and his apes boogieing with Baloo in "The Jungle
Book."
Misbehaving. Just the way Cole Porter loved it.
The scene is from the set of director Irwin Winkler's
"De-Lovely," a movie about the brilliant American
songwriter that wrapped up shooting last week 4 and
that the director emphatically declares will not be a
biopic. "There's only been one Cole Porter movie, and
it was a whitewash," the energetic 72-year-old Winkler
says, referring to the thin plot and wholesome tone of
the 1946 "Night and Day," starring Cary Grant.
Different times, of course, but that picture sailed
over what Winkler and scriptwriter Jay Cocks ("Gangs
of New York") see as the essence of the man: the
unconventional but emotionally intimate relationship
the gay Porter (Kevin Kline) shared with his socialite
wife, Linda Lee (Ashley Judd).
"Linda was so important to him throughout their life
together — she saw him find his voice," says Robert
Kimball, who has been the artistic advisor to the Cole
Porter Trust for 37 years and who visited the set in
June to see what Winkler was up to. "She honored and
respected him and introduced him to a wider cultural
world. And when he had relationships with men, Cole
looked to her for advice and approval.
"Friends who were there told me that at her funeral,
he cried like a baby." It is a love worthy of
cinematic exploration, though any movie about Cole
Porter is always going to be about the music. Winkler
will use about 30 songs to tell the Porters' love
story, and they remain, of course, some of the best
songs of the heart ever written ("Thirty songs — and I
wish we could use more," Winkler says with a twinkle).
But there will be no Louis Armstrong on the
"De-Lovely" soundtrack. No Ella. For the digital era,
Winkler has asked modern recording artists to step up
to the mike (hence Costello's bandleader). Instead of
Sarah Vaughan singing "It's De-Lovely," we get British
pop star Robbie Williams, and so on: from Diana Krall
("Just One of Those Things") to Natalie Cole ("Every
Time We Say Goodbye") and — more of a stretch, this —
Alanis Morissette ("Let's Do It [Let's Fall in
Love]"). The producers wanted Norah Jones too but
couldn't strike a deal. "She's got a wall of Grammys
in front of her," one executive laments.
Like the angel toting up the good and bad moments in
George Bailey's wonderful life, "De-Lovely" unfolds as
a retrospective accounting from the viewpoint of a
widowed, lonely and apparently broken man. Porter's
lyrics provide the guide for the story. It takes him
back to his fawned-upon childhood in Peru, Ind., and
follows as he becomes America's songwriting king of
musicals and movies. The journey will be stylish,
Winkler promises, with plenty of big production
numbers. The commercial backwash of "Moulin Rouge" and
"Chicago" shows no sign of easing, though the idea of
"De-Lovely" was pitched to the Porter estate trustees
in pre-"Chicago" 2000. (It will be released by MGM/UA
next year.)
Yet the film will not be all Art Deco drawing rooms
and bellinis at sunset.
Porter's life was marked by several tragedies, from
Linda's miscarriage and their later separation to the
bitter aftermath of the 1937 horse-riding accident
that crushed his legs and left him in pain until his
death in 1964 (Porter eventually had one leg
amputated).
It is his relationship with Linda upon which Winkler's
movie rests.
Crucially, the film travels through Porter's wasted
years in Europe in the post-World War I era, when he
was content to be the life of any party. Linda rescued
her husband from terminal self-indulgence, her
intervention unleashing a singular talent on American
popular music.
She was not about to watch Cole's talent atrophy on
the shelf of hedonism.
"Linda was saying to him, 'Take yourself seriously,' "
Kline says in London shortly before filming ended.
"Stop being a party boy and get to work."
Kline is himself a singer — "It was the music that
attracted me to the role," he says. "I wanted to be a
singer before I wanted to be an actor" — and will
carry about half the tunes in the movie. But much of
the love story's authenticity will depend on Judd's
ability to portray a believable muse. It is a terrific
challenge: to show the complicated love between a gay
man with an appetite for sexual adventure and the
woman who saw into his soul and drew out the genius.
"I just genuinely assume it's an alchemy I
understand," the 35-year-old Judd says as she watches
Costello rip into "Let's Misbehave" one more time.
"It's about believing in someone, something I know
about from being with my sister [Grammy-winning
Wynonna] and my husband [Scottish race car driver
Dario Franchitti], who has a rare and extraordinary
gift. It's a kind of compassion towards the character
of their gift."
Yet Porter was a complicated, mysterious guy, Kline
says, "and we don't know what happened behind closed
doors. You can read all the biographies you want, as
I've done, but in the end you sort of wheedle out a
compromise vision of the character."
And clearly there was a part of Porter that was
addicted to danger. "By every report, theirs was a
deep and abiding affection for one another," Kline
says of the marriage. But while Linda condoned his
bisexuality, he adds, "she became increasingly worried
when his search for sex became more and more
indiscreet."
For Winkler, that means getting the sexual calibration
right. Too much and "De-Lovely" descends into
campiness. Too sanitized and it risks the wrath of
those for whom Porter is a gay icon. Kline says the
movie will be "fairly explicit in terms of Cole's
appetites, though there is nothing sexually graphic on
screen. You'll see the kinds of excess to which he
indulged," the actor says. "He could get down and
dirty."
Facts aren't the only thing.
There is artistic risk, too, in Cocks' decision to
write a script that ignores the conventional
constraints of biography. Fresh from being pounded by
critics for the historical looseness of parts of his
"Gangs of New York" script, he fired off a preemptive
strike against would-be detractors this time, issuing
a one-page manifesto for the movie that warns his love
story won't be handcuffed by history.
"The broad outlines of his life are here but placed
within the framework of imagination, not scholarship,"
Cocks writes. He calls the script "an impressionistic
musical biography" in which "we've used facts like
notes in a melody, putting them together in a way that
may never have happened but that may give a truer,
deeper picture of the man, his work and — most
important — his heart."
(One departure the film takes is in the ages of the
couple: Lee was older than Porter; Kline, however, is
20 years older than Judd.)
Or, as "De-Lovely" producer Rob Cowan puts it, "Hey,
it's a movie." But that kind of talk can make Porter
purists jittery. There are different versions of how
"De-Lovely" originated: Winkler says the estate
approached him about making a film that might
stimulate sales of Porter's catalog; the trustees say
it was Winkler who approached them with the idea. But
the sides are clearly trying to accommodate each other
(for one thing, the estate's cooperation in dropping
its usual royalty fees on Porter songs will save the
filmmakers millions).
"I told them I had to tell the story as I saw fit and
they said 'fine,' " Winkler says matter-of-factly.
Winkler's credits as a producer range from "The Right
Stuff" to "GoodFellas," and as a director he made,
among other films, "Life as a House" with Kline in
2001. Porter historian Kimball says Winkler has the
benefit of the estate's doubts. "He's the pro,"
Kimball says. "Everyone wants to see the picture done
in what we called, in the old days, good taste. But
Irwin and Jay Cocks should have the right to make
their own movie. I may not like it. I don't want
people to do violence to it or make up the facts. But
there is no set way to do it, either." What Kimball
doesn't want to see at any cost is a lot of messing
around with Porter's lyrics. Respect the harmonies and
rhythms as much as you can.
But the words are sacred.
Ah, the lyrics. It is worth remembering that in
Porter's day, the music was not a special taste with a
section of his own at the back of music stores.
Back then it was American popular music (at least,
white American music). With his lyrical lists and
rhyming schemes, Porter was a sort of WASPy rapper for
the swing era: "Birds do it, bees do it, even educated
fleas do it." The songs were part of the cultural
ether.
How they will sound to the generation of what would be
his great-grandchildren is Winkler's gamble. "What
kind of word is 'beguine'?" a laughing Sheryl Crow
said to music producer Peter Asher after cutting her
vocal track for "Begin the Beguine" in a London
recording studio. "I sound like Doris Day."
Hardly. Crow's version of the standard is sung in a
minor key, with the rock chick delivering a bluesy,
aching ode to lost love.
The tension in that love is evident in the Venetian
ballroom scene — actually filmed in a genteel manor
house outside London that was rouged up to look
suitably decadent. At the time, Porter is in exile
from his destiny, and Linda has summoned Irving Berlin
and his wife to Venice to try to light the fire of
ambition.
So Chance is coming, but for the moment Kline's Porter
is making sure no piano goes unplayed. He is sitting
in the corner of the ballroom picking out the notes to
"You Do Something to Me" and casting lascivious
glances at the hard bods going past. Kline has a good
voice, and from the back of the room, Costello listens
and laughs.
"I've heard a few old recordings of Porter singing,
and he had a terrible voice," Costello says. "Awful.
Like a cat screeching from the bottom of a well."
(Kimball, more defensively, calls Porter's voice
"reedy.")
"Oh, he was a famously bad pianist too," Kline agrees.
"He had a pounding, oom-pah left hand. Oh baby, he did
not have a light touch." Kline laughs. "You know his
obituary in the New York Times read: 'Singer Cole
Porter,' " he continues. "Well, he was never a singer.
"But it's perfect for me. I've got a wonderful
built-in excuse for bad playing and singing."
>> Back